· 4 min read
I Can't Believe I Gave 1/5 on Student Feedback
I just submitted my student feedback, and I gave a lecturer not-so-good scores. My score started at 3/5, then it became 2/5, and after the last class today, it became 1/5. As a teaching assistant, I do hope that my students give me at least 4 (or 5), so I usually don’t give 3 or less. Objectively, I do not think that he is a bad teacher, or that he deserves that score. The way he makes me feel, though, is definitely negative.
If I taught the way he does, I would quit on the spot.
Being too grades-centric
Firstly, he uses grades to drive certain actions/behaviours. After every class, he asks students to recap the lesson, and he always ends by reminding us that it comes with participation points. This goes against my own teaching pedagogy, and I would forfeit grades, on principle. Just today, during a final graded presentation, we were graded for asking questions, and I refused to ask any, simply because I don’t agree with his pedagogy.
I would like to highlight the differences between my treatment of grades and his. In CS2040S, students are indeed graded for participation. I make it known to the students in the first lesson that participation is graded. I see it as explaining the rules of the game. I do not use grades to entice people to ask questions. Fundamentally, I believe that these things should be self-directed.
In my opinion, graded participation is justified, since grades are just a metric for what the course prioritises. On some instinctive level, we all chase grades anyway, so once it’s a policy, there’s no need for the teacher to push it further in class.
Conventions as ground truth
He also has a style guide on how to write emails to him, such as starting with a line asking how his day was. In class, he ranted about one email, asking “Can you imagine someone wrote me an email like this?” Since this is an English class, I understand why he teaches these conventions. However, these conventions are based on the assumptions of a particular business culture, and he presents them as the ground truth. Not a single time in class did I hear the word “convention”, and it irks me.
When I teach programming, I justify everything with a reason. Some things are purely convention. For those, I explain that people are more familiar with them, so following them makes code easier to read. Other things are stylistic, meaning there are several equally valid choices. For those, I simply say that my choice “makes me happy”. That’s a good enough reason for students to switch, and I’d want students to switch willingly.
Stereotype warning
In my experience, Asian students tend to listen without asking for a reason, while European students are more likely to ask why. (Being asked why can annoy me, because it feels like they don’t respect my authority. However, I also understand the value of being reasonable.)
Once, I told students to use the lab computers to get familiar with the environment. One of the exchange students said he didn’t need to, because he had a similar keyboard at home. I just said okay, because in university, people are old enough to make their own decisions. If this lecturer were in my position, I feel like he would have given a look of disappointment.
Conclusion
For the reasons stated above, I don’t vibe well with this lecturer. He pushes students with grades and conventions without giving a reason, while I try to give a reason for everything and let students choose.
Teaching is partly a performance, and as with any performance, the idea is to get people to like you. Once they like you, you can do anything. Once they dislike you, no matter what you do, they will dislike you.
Even so, being disliked isn’t the end of the world. I don’t take his grades to heart, and I hope he doesn’t take my feedback score to heart either. He’s just unlucky to have had me as a student.
To my past, current, and future students, feel free to comment on my teaching. I really do want your feedback, even if I end up disagreeing with it.
Update: an afterthought
Thinking about it more, at its core, it’s that this teacher treats students like children. He cares for them, in the sense that he gets worried if students are absent. By my standards, though, it’s too much micromanaging. As a teacher, I let students have autonomy, and guide them with reasons. It’s not all sunshine and rainbows, since I can’t make them do what I want, and that annoys me sometimes. Still, I’m not their parent, and it’s not my jurisdiction.



